SignOnSanDiego

Drought threatens southern steelhead

State biologist drafting plan to save rare sea-going trout

By Terry Rodgers
STAFF WRITER

May 20, 2002

Southern California's most severe drought on record is beginning to exact a toll on habitat and wildlife in a region with the greatest number of endangered species in the continental United States.

While snow and rainfall have been normal in other parts of the state, including the Sierra Nevada, the southern half of the state is far drier than usual.

Seasonal streams that normally don't dry up until midsummer are barren depressions or chains of shallow potholes choked with algae.

While the drought threatens a number of water-dependent plants and animals, conservationists are particularly concerned about the fate of southern steelhead, the rarest sea-going trout in the United States. State biologist Mary L. Larson is drafting an emergency plan to rescue the southern steelhead in San Mateo Creek along the northern border of Camp Pendleton this summer if the drought persists.

"We can't let these fish die," Larson said.

Six months ago, Larson became the first state Fish & Game Department biologist specifically assigned to coordinate restoration efforts of steelhead habitat in Southern California.

"We'd like to have a plan in place for this summer, so if the worst-case scenario happens, the fish won't die," she said.

She envisions a rescue plan similar to the practice at the Carmel River in Monterey County, where the steelhead and salmon are plucked from the river and taken upstream to deeper pools.

If upstream pools in San Mateo Creek are too dry, the rare steelhead could be taken to a state hatchery at Fillmore in Ventura County until the water level rises, she said.

She must persuade scientists with the National Marine Fisheries Service to go along with the plan. The policy of the federal agency, which takes over jurisdiction of the San Mateo Creek steelhead July 1, is not to intervene when nature threatens wildlife.

A few hundred southern steelhead are all that remain in the low-flowing streams between San Luis Obispo County and San Diego.

The southern steelhead is a type of rainbow trout that, like salmon, begins life in fresh water before going to sea. What makes the southern steelhead special is its genes. It is the oldest in the evolutionary chain of West Coast steelhead, which range as far north as the U.S.-Canada border.

Last week, Larson concluded a weeklong assessment of streams and rivers in Southern California.

Accompanied by Allen Greenwood, an amateur naturalist and expert on San Diego's wild trout, Larson hiked 21 miles and inspected 31 back-country streams.

She observed an ecosystem showing signs of stress from drought.

"It's August already in the foothills," she said.

At lower elevations, the few wildflowers that sprouted this spring have been overrun by non-native rye grass.

San Diego is on track to its lowest-ever rainfall seasonal total since 1850, when record-keeping began. Since July 1, 2001, 3.02 inches of rain has fallen. The season ends June 30. The National Weather Service said this past winter was the driest on record for San Diego and Riverside counties. San Diego County has 40 plants and animal species listed as either threatened or endangered, more than any county in the nation.

While most of the plants and animals native to the chaparral have evolved to withstand drought, biologists are concerned that some endangered species could be pushed closer to the edge of extinction.

"We would expect to see reduced reproduction this year for species that are water-dependent, such as endangered arroyo toads," said Jane Hendron, spokeswoman for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in Carlsbad.

Scientists at Pepperdine University recently documented a decline in egg production among frogs and newts in the Santa Monica Mountains.

Annual wildflowers and clover that serve as the host plant for the endangered Quino checkerspot butterfly sprouted and quickly wilted in the parched San Diego back country.

"In the lower elevations closer to sea level, everything is pretty crispy," said Meredith Osborne, a botanist for the state. "The annual plants are really very sparse this year."

Drought-tolerant sage scrub and chaparral are in bloom, but relatively few pollinating insects are bouncing from blossom to blossom.

"You can't belive how bad it is in the back country," said Greenwood, 60, who has been exploring San Diego's creeks and rivers since he was a teen.

"Water from the snowpack in the Laguna Mountains wasn't enough this year to charge the aquifers feeding the springs that supply the streams," he said. Southern steelhead were thought to be extinct south of Malibu Creek in Los Angeles County until they were discovered 100 miles south at San Mateo Creek in February 1999.

Walking with state biologists after the discovery, Greenwood counted 46 adult steelhead in the pools in the lower and middle reaches of the creek.

Scientists aren't sure how many are still alive. State biologists in January found several steelhead in the deepest pools in San Mateo Creek and a tributary, Devil's Canyon Creek, northeast of Camp Pendleton.

The creek originates in Riverside County from springs in the Santa Ana Mountains. The farthest the steelhead can go upstream is Tenaja Falls about 20 miles from the Pacific Ocean.

After hiking to the base of the falls last week, Greenwood and Larson were disappointed to find the flow had been reduced to a garden-hose-like trickle.

"The falls here should be raging with water," said Greenwood. "This is how it normally looks in late August or September."

Larson said she's got plenty of ideas for helping the steelhead.

Perhaps water districts can be persuaded to time their releases of water below dams to help the fish. Maybe ranchers can cooperate by fixing their ponds so non-native bass and other fish aren't flushed into the creek during floods. Along the lower reaches of the creek, where the stream bed is too wide and shallow, the channel could be deepened and replanted with willows, sycamores and other native trees to shade the water.

The state Coastal Conservancy has $800,000 earmarked for steelhead restoration at the creek, and Larson is eager to set up a committee to review grant applications.

"It's going to take 20 years or more," she said. "We may not see southern steelhead de-listed (from the endangered species list), but we'll make great strides."

Terry Rodgers: (619) 542-4566; terry.rodgers@uniontrib.com

NOTICE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C., section 107, some material is provided without permission from the copyright owner, only for purposes of criticism, comment, scholarship and research under the "fair use" provisions of federal copyright laws. These materials may not be distributed further, except for "fair use," without permission of the copyright owner.